Nokia N8 Review

5 months ago, I shut down Symbian-Guru.com, my personal project of nearly 4 years. The decision was based mostly on the horrendous experience that was the Nokia N97, and I just couldn’t wait to see if the N8 was any better, especially based on early previews. Fortunately, the folks at Nokia are awful friendly, and sent me an N8 review unit anyways, just so I could see for myself if it was an improvement.

I’ve used the N8 for a little over a week, and to be honest, I’m quite impressed with it. Using the N8, it’s very clear that Nokia took in all the feedback from the N97 and sought to integrate it into the N8 experience. The build quality is rock solid, with high-quality materials. There is plenty of memory in all the right places (RAM, ROM, etc), and the phone feels really snappy, even without a full 1GHz Snapdragon in there. They’ve also worked on the actual experience, but you can read the full review to find out where.

Hardware

The Nokia N8 is easily the most solidly build Nokia smartphone I’ve ever used. The materials are high quality, and the pieces are put together tightly, with no looseness or gaps. The middle portion of the phone is metal, while the top and bottom caps are plastic, to allow the cellular signal to get through. The 3.5-inch nHD display is covered with Gorilla Glass, which lets it withstand plenty of abuse without getting scratched.

The 3.5-inch AMOLED display is awesome, though – I can easily read it in sunlight, much better than my Nexus One, which I simply cannot read in direct sunlight. It’s bright, shows great colors, and is pleasantly responsive – Nokia did a great job with the display on the N8, there’s no doubt about that.

There are only a few buttons on the Nokia N8, and honestly, they’re a mixed bag. The power button on the top of the phone is small but easy to press, and the menu button on the bottom left corner of the front of the phone is the same (though I can’t figure out why on earth it’s offset like it is). Along the right side of the phone is the volume rocker, slide-lock button, and the camera button. The volume rocker on my unit is awful – it’s entirely too mushy and you can almost press the whole thing in without really pushing it. You’ve really got to apply some pressure to get the volume up/down recognized. The camera button, on the other hand, is just a bit too stiff, making it somewhat tricky to take good photos without moving the camera just a bit in pushing the button.

Software

There are two parts to the software part of the Nokia N8, in my opinion. First, there’s the improvements made to the base Symbian platform from S60v5 to Symbian^3. It’s not a complete rewrite like it probably should have been, but there are some major improvements, nonetheless. Second, there’s the Nokia layer to the Symbian platform, which includes a few Nokia-specific applications and the Ovi Store experience.

Platform Level

The best way to sum up the changes from S60v5 to Symbian^3 is that they cleaned things up quite nicely. It’s still far from perfect, but it is definitely improved. The first thing you’ll notice, if you used any of Nokia’s earlier S60v5 devices, is that you only have to tap things once – the double-tap is gone, for the most part. They still need to tweak this a bit, as I often selected things instead of scrolling, specifically in longer lists like the music player.

The menus, however, are still not as organized as most people seem to prefer. Whereas other platforms, like iOS and Android, just toss all your apps in a single scrollable menu, Symbian has a bit more organization out of the box. Apps in the main menu are tucked into various subfolders, grouped with similar applications. Office apps are with other office apps, games with games, media with media. Of course, it’s Nokia’s opinion on where these go, so you may disagree with some of the placements.

iOS and Android take a different approach to this, and I can’t really say which is better. Android gives you a number of homescreens for organization, mixing widgets and icons and everything. iOS, on the other hand, is actually the most similar to Symbian in that it lets the user organize the main menu freely, including subfolders and such. The difference is that Symbian has a default organization, while iOS lets you start from scratch.

The browser on the N8 still sucks, but at least Nokia knows it and is reportedly working on a brand new one that will be delivered to the N8 via OTA firmware update sometime early in 2011. It’s a full web browser with Flash built-in, so it’s technically competitive, but it’s just slow as Christmas and clunky to navigate. Symbian^3 does finally give users the option to change the default browser from stock to Opera Mini or something if they so choose, but that’s not really a very good solution.

Text input on Symbian is embarrassing, to say the least. In portrait mode, your only option is a standard numeric keypad, with T9 predictive text. There is no portrait QWERTY keyboard (that’s also expected to be available in that upcoming firmware update). Honestly, I don’t mind T9 – in most cases, it’s actually much faster, especially when you can only use one hand. The problem, however, is that some input fields let you use the predictive feature, while others force you to use multi-tap – you know, press the 6 key three times to enter an ‘o’ – which is completely retarded.

Also, one of the best parts of T9 you may remember from your older phone is that the predictive part was almost always the same – this allowed you to quickly get to the point where you could type an entire paragraph on your phone without ever having to actually look at it. It was brilliant, and unfortunately, that feature is broken on the N8. A great example of this is the punctuation. Sometimes, pressing the 1 key and then # to scroll through the options would give you a period and then a comma, while other times the question mark followed the period, with the comma pushed down the line a bit. Just endlessly frustrating.

When you rotate the phone to landscape mode, thankfully, there is a full QWERTY keyboard. The buttons on this keyboard are nicely sized and it finally has a bit of predictive software, offering to not only auto-complete your words, but auto-correct, too, if you choose that option. Unfortunately, Symbian missed the big opportunity with software-based keyboards – context. The landscape QWERTY keyboard on the N8 lacks all of the little extras that make the iPhone and Android’s onscreen keyboards so dang handy. There are no contextual buttons at all – such as a dedicated ‘www/.com‘ button in the browser, a smiley button in the messaging app, and so on.

Also, symbols are a nightmare, as you have to manually switch to ‘symbol mode’ each time – there is no option to long-press certain letters to get a symbol like there is on the HTC or Swype keyboards. Speaking of, there is a version of Swype for the N8 that is freely available on the Ovi Store. Unfortunately, this is only a landscape keyboard replacement – it does not include the excellent Swype portrait QWERTY, so you’re still stuck with the T9 in portrait mode.

Nokia/Ovi

Unfortunately, the Nokia N8 suffers much the same fate the N97 did when it launched – many of Nokia’s Ovi services simply aren’t yet available. Of course, there’s an updated version of Ovi Maps on the Beta Labs, which is freakin awesome, and the integrated Nokia Messaging for Email, which is also quite good. I was also pleased to see Ovi Sync built-in, but more on that in a moment. Ovi Chat is nowhere to be seen, which is unfortunate, as it was nicely integrated with the contact list in the Nokia N97.

I’ve tried Ovi Sync before, and tried desperately to get it to work for me. I’ve never once had it work properly, but I figured I’d give it another go. First, I logged into my account on my computer, and disconnected any old phones that might have hung around. Then, I manually deleted every one of the contacts I had from before, logging out and then back in to make sure they were all really gone. Next, synced the N8 with my Google account, using the instructions from my friend Dennis at WapReview.com. This went smoothly, and now I had all my contacts and calendar entries from my Google account on the N8. I then removed the Google account, and was pleased to see that my contacts/calendar entries remained on the phone.

Next, I setup the Ovi Sync account on the N8. It was really quite easy, only really asking for my username/password, and it gave me a few options on what to sync and how frequently. I let the first sync go through, and gave it a few minutes to populate in my online Ovi account. Much to my dismay, I somehow had multiple duplicate entries, including contacts that I had long since deleted. It appears as though manually deleting the contacts online didn’t actually delete them. What a steaming pile of fail. Fortunately, I was able to hard reset the N8 to delete everything, and start over with only my Google account, and everything has been running smoothly.

Media

The Nokia N8 is the first real touchscreen Nseries, in the original purpose and design of the ‘Nseries’ branding.

When I connected the N8 to my computer via USB, I wasn’t hassled with a popup asking me to choose the type of connection – it just worked and showed up in MediaMonkey with no issues or configuration needed. I was able to transfer 1,300 music tracks in a matter of minutes – a task that would have taken hours with the N97. The tracks immediately showed up in my music library, as well – no refreshing needed (though I did see the option to do so in the menu). The music player is still essentially the same as what you’re used to with Symbian, with some small changes. There is still no support for a ratings system, and it doesn’t seem to track or synchronize metadata such as playcount or last played.

I was pleased to discover that the music automatically paused if my headphones came unplugged, a feature Symbian-lovers have requested for years. The speakers are insanely loud, as I would have expected.

There are a number of videos pre-loaded on the Nokia N8, including a few TRON ones, possibly hinting at more collaboration with the movie when it hits theatres in December. Of course, these look astounding on the N8’s high-resolution display, and play smoothly, as well. I tested a few videos from various sources, as well, and was pleased to see that the N8 was able to handle them without any conversion needed – another big step forward from Nokia.

The Nokia N8’s camera will completely blow your mind. It’s that good. I’m not a professional photographer – I’m a point-and-shoot photographer, and I rarely tinker with any settings. I love the spontaneity in photos, really – the ability to just pull my phone out and quickly capture the moment, and the N8 doesn’t disappoint. There are a handful of photos that I took with the Nokia N8 available at my Flickr page here, or you can check out the N8 User Group for more photos taken with the N8. Video capture is equally awesome, as you can see in the sample below:

httpvh://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8dpHJz7W1Q

The Nokia N8 also has onboard apps for editing photos and videos, something we haven’t seen on a Nokia since the venerable N95. Of course, they’re somewhat limited in options, but they’re easy to use and work quite well, nonetheless. The Nokia N8 is a content creation machine, plain and simple, and that’s why I believe it’s the first real touchscreen Nseries. It’s similar to the N95 in that regard – a true multimedia computer as originally envisioned.

Here’s a video that I captured and edited completely on the Nokia N8:

httpvh://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NJTH69_moPs

Apps

This is where I’m probably going to lose a few readers, and I’m OK with that. It’s a fact that there are not as many apps available for the Symbian platform as there are for Android or iOS. I currently have over 70 apps on my T-Mobile G2 (you can browse them on AppBrain) and for the most part, I actively use every one of them at least once a week, if not more.

That being said, the lack of apps is NOT Symbian’s biggest problem right now. Most of the ‘big ones’ are already available – Mobbler, Gravity, Nimbuzz, Pixelpipe, etc. Even many of the niche apps, like Foursquare and OpenTable, are readily available on the Ovi Store. The reason I don’t think this is a big issue is because Symbian already has many of the features that apps bring on other platforms. I also felt more productive when I was using the N8. There were fewer distractions, and I spent less time wasting time on the phone.

Ovi Store

Speaking of, Ovi Store on the N8 is nearly equal to the Android Market on v2.2 (FroYo), in my opinion. The overall experience of browsing through apps and getting details on applications is basically the same, and that’s pretty good. The biggest thing I was missing is the ability to check for updates to applications. It’s very likely, however, that the apps on my N8 simply didn’t have updates, but that’s also a problem, in my opinion. Overall though, the Ovi Store team should be congratulated – they’ve done some incredible work taking a horrendous experience and making it significantly better. I’m anxious to see what other improvements they have in the pipeline.

Conclusion

Overall, the Nokia N8 is surprisingly good. My two biggest complaints are the browser and text input options, both of which are, apparently, getting a major overhaul with the v2.0 firmware expected in early 2011. The hardware is top-notch, and feels really well put together. If you’ve been using an older Symbian device and wanting an upgrade, I would recommend the N8 without any hesitation. As with most of Nokia’s high-end smartphones, it’s probably a good idea to wait until the 2.0 firmware is available – chances are, the phone will be ~$100-150 cheaper by then, and you’ll get some major benefits with fewer bugs.

The software can always be updated – the hardware, though, you’re stuck with. Fortunately, the N8 does well here. The processor isn’t as pokey as I anticipated (Symbian does really good with lower specs than other platforms), the battery life is awesome, and there is plenty of internal memory to go around (including the ROM C: storage that the N97 seemed to be missing). The camera will rock your face off, and if you’re a content creator, the editing and uploading functions definitely make the N8 stand out.

I wouldn’t say the N8 is an ‘iPhone Killer’ or an ‘Android Killer’, by any stretch of the imagination. I also don’t think everyone wants that. Some people out there just like Symbian, or dislike the other platforms. The N8 is a great device for them.

Published by rcadden

Just a dude with a phone.

37 thoughts on “Nokia N8 Review

  1. I remember you saying in your closing post in SG that if S^3 was good enough, you would consider reopening SG when S^4 released. Now that its the continuous update system, does the N8 count as a step forward into you being optimistic enough about current Nokia devices to reopen the site?

  2. Good review.I was looking forward to your take even though this device has been sufficiently covered, and then some. After finally getting my hands on one yesterday I cannot see why anyone would choose it over the competition, all things being equal. ie, paying full price. The user experience first impressions make no compelling arguments to halt your shopping.

    Beyond that, Nokia’s app variety and overall supporting ecosystem falls short. Like you wrote, the main apps are there but the lack of useful esoteric ones would keep Android and iPhone users from switching brands. For example, my bank has an app, iPhone’s first then came an Android one. When I asked if a Nokia app was being developed the answer was no. Several other apps I use, I’m on a Desire btw, have iPhone counterparts with uncertain Nokia plans.

    Nokia have fallen too far behind and hardware tricks are simply not going to be enough.

  3. Good review.I was looking forward to your take even though this device has been sufficiently covered, and then some. After finally getting my hands on one yesterday I cannot see why anyone would choose it over the competition, all things being equal. ie, paying full price. The user experience first impressions make no compelling arguments to halt your shopping.

    Beyond that, Nokia’s app variety and overall supporting ecosystem falls short. Like you wrote, the main apps are there but the lack of useful esoteric ones would keep Android and iPhone users from switching brands. For example, my bank has an app, iPhone’s first then came an Android one. When I asked if a Nokia app was being developed the answer was no. Several other apps I use, I’m on a Desire btw, have iPhone counterparts with uncertain Nokia plans.

    Nokia have fallen too far behind and hardware tricks are simply not going to be enough.

  4. Great review, but it looks like you’re trying very hard not to say that Symbian still sucks compared with what’s on the market, readily available today (webOS, iOS, Android, Windows Phone 7).

  5. I suppose that it is a major step forward compared to the N97.

    That said, it is far from being an Android or an iPhone killer. It’s likely that in a couple of months, we’ll start to see Android phones with A9 dual core CPUs, Gingerbread, a 720p screen, and a camera that rivals (if not exceeds this one). Unless they are willing to update at the same pace as say, Android, the software advantages are going to be working against Nokia, not for Nokia.

    Still, at least Nokia is (somewhat) more competitive and more competition is always good for the consumer.

  6. I suppose that it is a major step forward compared to the N97.

    That said, it is far from being an Android or an iPhone killer. It’s likely that in a couple of months, we’ll start to see Android phones with A9 dual core CPUs, Gingerbread, a 720p screen, and a camera that rivals (if not exceeds this one). Unless they are willing to update at the same pace as say, Android, the software advantages are going to be working against Nokia, not for Nokia.

    Still, at least Nokia is (somewhat) more competitive and more competition is always good for the consumer.

  7. Good luck getting firmware updates in the NAM market. I currently have an E72 and it is at least two updates behind the rest of the world. I was thinking of going for an E7, but I doubt Nokia would improve their record of firmware updates to the NAM market.I will be looking elsewhere….

  8. Good review. So depressing to read that Nokia essentially failed to spend any significant time, looking at the competitor’s keyboards. Not just an opportunity lost, as there are so many good ideas that can be cherry-picked, elsewhere; Nokia’s really delivered a poor input experience.

    It’s as if they set out to build a great point-and-shoot camera, that can function as a merely so-so smart phone.

    Let’s see if the firmware update can fix most of what’s wrong with the N8.

    1. I’m really anxious to see the firmware update, as well. It’s sad to be in that situation, though. It seems that’s Nokia’s typical M.O., though – release a phone with half-baked firmware, then release a really rock-star firmware a few months later.

      Sure would be great if they could just release the good firmware from the get-go. The N95 and N97 both suffered the same fault, as did some of their recent Eseries.

      1. And then there’s your experience syncing with Ovi. As much as I don’t particularly care for Nokia PC Sync, I live in terror at the prospect of having to use Ovi to sync, instead. Ain’t no firmware update gonna fix that bad boy!

  9. Good review. So depressing to read that Nokia essentially failed to spend any significant time, looking at the competitor’s keyboards. Not just an opportunity lost, as there are so many good ideas that can be cherry-picked, elsewhere; Nokia’s really delivered a poor input experience.

    It’s as if they set out to build a great point-and-shoot camera, that can function as a merely so-so smart phone.

    Let’s see if the firmware update can fix most of what’s wrong with the N8.

  10. Oh yea; very nice review Ricky. Wondering where mine is @brighthand (uhmm) – but we’ve got some similar conclusions.

    I’ll say this though, it wasn’t until a few weeks after having written the review for the N8 that it grew on me enough to consider it as a second device to my N97 (I know, I like my green machine a lot). But, I do have some good vibes about the E7, especially if some of the UI, browser, and Ovi issues can be ironed out.

    By the way; this review is one of those where I can say “it never felt like you left Nokia/Symbian” but, you have matured past being more fan than analyst.

  11. Oh yea; very nice review Ricky. Wondering where mine is @brighthand (uhmm) – but we’ve got some similar conclusions.

    I’ll say this though, it wasn’t until a few weeks after having written the review for the N8 that it grew on me enough to consider it as a second device to my N97 (I know, I like my green machine a lot). But, I do have some good vibes about the E7, especially if some of the UI, browser, and Ovi issues can be ironed out.

    By the way; this review is one of those where I can say “it never felt like you left Nokia/Symbian” but, you have matured past being more fan than analyst.

  12. I’m still on the fence on buying an N8, as my N900 is still serving faithfully. I’m glad to hear the Ovi Store client on the phone is improved, but I will say, the Ovi website still sucks pretty bad. Hopefully that’s something that’s up for improvement.

  13. Having spent two weeks with the N8 I agree with all your points. Coming from a Nokia N900 where everything works well, the browser experience on the N8 was appauling. I shouldn’t have to load up Opera to make the experience better. Not having a physical keyboard is also another major negative for me, although after I installed SWYPE I must say the N8 improved greatly, but then that is the software and not the device making it happen. OVI store on the N8 is a pleasure and I ended up installing tons of applications and games etc, but the best application was SPB mobile shell 3.7. It makes the N8 so much better and a lot more fun. The highlights for me is the camera and video recorder. They are incredible on this device, only wish Nokia included an optical zoom. I am giving the phone back to WOMWorld/Nokia tomorrow with a little sadness, but can’t wait to get back to my N900.

  14. I like the coffee video. Quite unique! what is the song playing in the background? – did you have the Nokia N8 Producer headgear accommadating the N8. (nicely done however you did it!).

  15. I like the coffee video. Quite unique! what is the song playing in the background? – did you have the Nokia N8 Producer headgear accommadating the N8. (nicely done however you did it!).

  16. Hi Ricky:
    Could you possibly post a pic of the N8 mount you received with the Joby GorillaPod? Love to mount mine on a tripod but haven’t found a suitable, convenient mounting device.
    Thanks, and Happy Holidays!

  17. Hi Ricky:
    Could you possibly post a pic of the N8 mount you received with the Joby GorillaPod? Love to mount mine on a tripod but haven’t found a suitable, convenient mounting device.
    Thanks, and Happy Holidays!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s