My First Kindle Experience

I bought my wife a Kindle 2 a few months ago, when the refurbs were on sale for ~$100. She reads a TON, so I had been eyeing them for a while, and jumped on it when they hit a more comfortable price-point. After trying to finagle some free e-books onto the device (not a great experience), I finally caved and purchased an e-book from Amazon. I bought Making Ideas Happen, which was recommended recently by my friend Chris Freeland.



Purchasing Content

As expected from Amazon, the masters of online purchasing, the buying experience was seamless. I purchased the book from my computer (because I had Chris’ post in my Google Reader starred items) and chose to have it delivered wirelessly to the Kindle. Within probably 1 minute of clicking the ‘purchase’ button, the book arrived on our Kindle and we had an email confirmation in Christina’s inbox.

You can purchase books and other content directly on the Kindle, thanks to its built-in wireless. I personally find this a bit slow and clunky with the e-ink display, but I suppose if you knew what book you wanted, it wouldn’t be a horrid experience.

Reading Content

kindle2The Kindle 2 has a smaller 6-inch display which is a few inches smaller than a standard size book (or at least the ones I used to read). As such, I felt like I was buzzing through the content, since I was constantly pressing the ‘Next Page’ button. You can easily tweak the font to be smaller, thus fitting more in the space, so I suppose it’s just a matter of personal preference (and how good your eyesight is).

The e-ink display is perfect for reading books and other printed content. Because it has no backlight, you can read it in just about any lighting or situation with no issues. Unfortunately, it doesn’t have a backlight, so like a book, you won’t be reading in the dark without a USB clip-on light or something. The display is more-or-less grayscale, and even the background is darkened, much like a normal page in a book. It’s really an entirely different experience than the brightly-lit LCD and OLED displays that I’m used to looking at, and I noticed that my eyes didn’t hurt after extended use, as well.

To get an idea of how much better (or worse) this e-ink display was, I installed the Kindle for Android application on my Nexus One. Granted, this is a MUCH smaller screen (3.7-inches), but I wanted to compare the readability of OLED vs e-ink. After about half an hour on my Nexus One, it became abundantly clear why people prefer e-ink. Of course, the Kindle for Android app lets you adjust the display a bit, but there’s still no real comparison.

One drawback to e-ink, though, that did, admittedly, get rather frustrating, is its refresh rate – that is, the quickness (or lack thereof) with which it is able to change things on the screen. Once you click the ‘Next Page’ button, expect to wait about 1/2 second before you can continue reading. Similarly, using other features, which I’ll talk about shortly, becomes a painfully slow process. In a world where digital toys continue to move faster and faster, it’s quite odd to see something move so slow. However, after a few page-turns, I rather appreciated this sluggishness – books shouldn’t be blown through, but rather read slowly. It’s almost like a built-in brake for us Internet-speedy-types, and I like it.

Sharing Content

Yes, there is a social aspect to reading books on the Kindle, but it’s so subtle, you’re not likely to get distracted by it (which is *just* barely the acceptable level of interaction needed when reading). For starters, there’s a social highlighter feature. As you’re reading a book on the Kindle, you’ll see various places that have a *very* light dotted line, along with text such as ’37 highlights’ beneath it. This tells you how many other people who’ve read this book have underlined that specific text. Odds are, it’s something you want to either re-read a few times, or highlight yourself. These ‘suggested’ highlights are so light, I almost missed the first one – you can also turn them off completely if you want, but I found it really helpful as I was reading.

There is also a more active social aspect if you want to share a portion of text with your social network of choice. I haven’t set this up, mainly because I want to be reading and not worrying about Twitter or Facebook, but it’s there, nonetheless (and it might be handy here or there).

Experiencing Content

I used to read a ton of books when I was younger – mostly spiritual authors such as John Eldredge, Donald Miller, Brennan Manning, C.S. Lewis, and the like. I would go through five or six books a year, taking notes in the sidebar and underlining all over the place. I have a bookshelf in my office full of books, most of which I’ve read a few times over. Since technology gripped my soul, I haven’t really taken the time to really read a book like I used to.

I honestly don’t know if the Kindle would change that or not. I’m going to finish reading ‘Making Ideas Happen’ on it, and see what I think. Already, I’m enjoying the device itself – it’s super thin and light, feels solid in your hand, I could, theoretically, carry my entire bookshelf on it. The battery life is insane, too, though that’s not surprising with a monochrome display.

Overall, I’d say the experience matched my expectations dead on. There are some sacrifices (battery-powered, slow screen refresh, etc), but there are also some big wins (small and light, easy on the eyes, social highlighting, easy purchase). It’s a bit of an investment up front (I got this Kindle 2 for $100, but they normally go for $139-189, depending on the model). I can say without a doubt that I wish I’d had one of these in high school and college, when I was lugging around monstrous textbooks that I often couldn’t sell used because there was a ‘new edition’. The upfront cost would quickly have been covered by the convenience.

Have you tried an e-book reader? What’s your take? Widgets

Published by rcadden

Just a dude with a phone.

10 thoughts on “My First Kindle Experience

  1. Very helpful review, Ricky! I have one of those new $139 6″ Kindle WiFi models on order, but I’m thinking of canceling. The biggest drawback for me is that I am a big library user (we have excellent libraries here), and their DRM-free electronic books don’t work on Kindle (or at least not in any easy way). They supposedly work better with the Sony reader, but I hate to invest money in hardware that doesn’t have much market share.

    I guess I’ll just have to keep reading the old fashioned way…

  2. Hi just got the Graphite DX and I love it, people say that ipad is good for reading, but while it is an over great device, the e-ink on the kindle just kills it for reading.
    The pearl e-ink screen on the graphite kindle dx and soon-to-be released kindle looks even better.
    Btw, ricky you want to check out the oberon case for kindle.

  3. As mentioned, I tried a few methods of getting free e-books (legitimately) onto the Kindle and while I was successful, they ended up being a much more inferior experience overall. Kinda sad, really.

  4. Thanks for the thoughts Ricky. Very nice to hear these sort of first impressions and helps give an idea of the pros and cons.

    Certainly the main thing that would give me pause is the difficulty of adding open e-pub format stuff to the device. I believe the Nook supports that format, which is a definite plus. I’m not sure, however, if the Nook then allows you to import stuff purchased from Amazon (I can’t imagine it does).

    So we’re left with a situation where you’ve got these walled gardens of content, which is god damn bullshit. I need to research it more, but you’d think people would have learnt from the mess that DRM caused when it came to audio. If I buy something, I want to be able to do whatever the hell I want with it.


  5. I was hesitant to get an e-reader for that specific reason. What opened it up for me was the various Kindle clients for different platforms – Windows, iOS, Android, etc. I’m confident that no matter what I choose to use in the future, I’ll still have access to the content I’ve purchased for the Kindle.

    I was also quite disappointed with the lack of free reading options. I realize the Kindle is the same business model as disposable razors and inkjet printers and the like (sell the unit cheap, make money on the replaceable parts/content), but I was still hoping for something. I was even more disturbed to see that many of the titles that are free on Gutenberg and other legitimate free ebook sites were available for purchase on the Kindle. Granted, they were like, $1-2, but still.

    I did manage to put a few free titles on the Kindle, but they weren’t formatted properly and looked like complete garbage – just not worth the hassle at all.

  6. Ricky I’m thinking of getting my kids a Kindle, but was just wondering do you need to enter your amazon password each time you want to purchase something or is it always a 1-click purchase. Don’t want the kids buying stuff willy nilly!

  7. I’m sure as well that Amazon Kindle purchases will remain available for the foreseeable future. It does just seem a shame to not have the choice. That idea that a book might be available on one platform but not the other, and because you’ve picked a certain platform you can’t read it on your e-reading device.

    New Kindle was just announced which sounds like it’s improved the page-turning speed a whole chunk – as well as making the device a lot lighter and smaller.

    1. I got a Kindle 3rd gen for my birthday. I’m totally in love with it. Have read a number of books already, and am 1/3 through the Count of Monte Cristo which I downloaded from and it reads very well altogether.

  8. just got myself a kindle DX …
    read The White Tiger on it and am now reading The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo series …
    Awesome device …
    Love it !!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s