Why The Nokia Booklet 3G Has 1GB Of RAM

Nokia has taken plenty of heat for the 1GB of RAM in its Booklet 3G, the company’s first netbook (or tiny laptop, whatever you want to call it, it’s a netbook). However, as I’ve done before, I think it’s important to understand the real problem behind this 1GB of RAM, as many sites/people do not seem to correctly present the problem.

First off, let’s get one thing clear: all netbooks ship with 1GB of RAM. You simply cannot order one with more than 1GB of RAM pre-installed, even from Dell, who normally lets users custom build their computers. As I understand it, this is a limitation set in place by Intel on its Atom processors, which pretty much all netbooks use. Go ahead, check on Amazon.com. (Apparently, this is set to change soon, but it hasn’t yet). Update: According to this, it’s not something Intel limits, but rather Microsoft for netbooks that have Windows pre-installed.

So then, what’s the problem? The problem is in the hardware design of the Nokia Booklet 3G. Using the solid aluminum casing, Nokia neglected to build in a way for users to easily upgrade the RAM themselves. I also confirmed with Nokia that the Booklet 3G’s RAM isn’t user-accessible, and even if it was, it’s soldered in, so you couldn’t remove it anyways. This, my friends, is the real problem.

Other netbook manufacturers get around the 1GB limit by making it super-easy for users to upgrade the RAM. Take, for example, my Asus 1000HE. On the bottom of this netbook is a small hatch. If you remove the screws, you’ll find you have direct access to the 1000HE’s RAM, which you can easily remove and replace with a 2GB card. In fact, when I ordered mine, Amazon recommended the 2GB stick, which cost an additional $25, and took 2 minutes to install. Here’s a video showing how easy it is:

httpv://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FFFe7ZAXjvc

So, first, it wasn’t Nokia being cheap or stupid when they put only 1GB of RAM in the Booklet 3G – that’s just part of netbooks, for the time being. However, it was completely Nokia’s doing that there isn’t an easy way for the user to replace the current 1GB stick of RAM with a much better 2GB stick, and this is something that future Booklets will hopefully not be affected with.

Published by rcadden

Just a dude with a phone.

4 thoughts on “Why The Nokia Booklet 3G Has 1GB Of RAM

  1. From what I understand, M$ doesn't place the same limitation on it's Windows 7 netbooks that it does on it's XP netbooks — so hopefully you'll be able to start seeing Win7 netbooks with 2gb ram soon enough.

  2. Microsoft does indeed only allow to sell the cheaper netbook license of Windows 7 if the machine got 1GB RAM, but nothing here is stopping Nokia from selling the more expensive and normal laptop OEM license of Windows 7, especially not considering it's an expensive netbook already to begin with.Also, while I dislike the fact the RAM is soldered into the motherboard, it does have a nice advantage too, which is a more energy-efficient way to communicate with the RAM, which gives better battery times.If this Nokia Booklet had 2GB in it, it would have been perfect for me, even if it was soldered in too cause I value as good battery times as possible and like the fact that this machine is energyefficient enough to not need any fan, that's class. But 1GB is simply not good enough today, Windows and various misc programs and a few browser tabs take up a lot of RAM, not to mention Nokias own software that require quite a bit too, like the new Ovi Suite. With a 1GB machine the swapfile has to work like mad, so a 2GB machine would already be a noticeably smoother experience.So my advice to Nokia is, give the machine 2GB and sell it with a normal laptop license with Windows, and I will buy it right away. Cause the 1GB is a serious flaw to me.

    1. 1 Gb is not enough for Windows7 šŸ™‚ I cant understand why Nokia didn’t sell booklets with linux? On my booklet Ubuntu 12.XX works great!!! Some problems with GPS, but will work on it.

  3. Microsoft does indeed only allow to sell the cheaper netbook license of Windows 7 if the machine got 1GB RAM, but nothing here is stopping Nokia from selling the more expensive and normal laptop OEM license of Windows 7, especially not considering it's an expensive netbook already to begin with.Also, while I dislike the fact the RAM is soldered into the motherboard, it does have a nice advantage too, which is a more energy-efficient way to communicate with the RAM, which gives better battery times.If this Nokia Booklet had 2GB in it, it would have been perfect for me, even if it was soldered in too cause I value as good battery times as possible and like the fact that this machine is energyefficient enough to not need any fan, that's class. But 1GB is simply not good enough today, Windows and various misc programs and a few browser tabs take up a lot of RAM, not to mention Nokias own software that require quite a bit too, like the new Ovi Suite. With a 1GB machine the swapfile has to work like mad, so a 2GB machine would already be a noticeably smoother experience.So my advice to Nokia is, give the machine 2GB and sell it with a normal laptop license with Windows, and I will buy it right away. Cause the 1GB is a serious flaw to me.

Leave a Reply to Janusz Artur Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s